-2

There's a lot of debate going on about questions and tags for individual languages. Personally, I think they should be on topic, as most people on here will be learning (or teaching) one or more specific languages.

However, one idea might be to lean more towards language groups, such as Romance Languages, Slavic Languages, etc, on the basis that the process of learning one language in a group would be similar to another?

  • 2
    We should wait for a clear consensus before we start making decisions based on it. – Downgoat Apr 6 '16 at 15:18
  • 3
    I'm not sure what "people aren't keen on individual language questions/tags" is responding to... We have several questions that talk about specific languages, and we have a meta post directly addressing the issue. But more to the point here, what kind of question would you ask about a language group? Lets see an example, and decide if it fits on its own merits, rather than based on some unknown abstract concept. – Flimzy Apr 6 '16 at 19:34
2

Some questions apply to language families, but I doubt that it's the majority. Language families are mostly grouped by vocabulary, they can have rather different grammar, spelling, phonology, etc.

A tag like on a question about, say, how to train oneself to pronounce the letter R, or when in a curriculum to teach the subjunctive, would be meaningless. Such a question should be tagged or or etc. as appropriate: these questions have completely different answers in different Romance languages.

There are questions that apply to a set of languages, not necessarily grouped by historical families. Such questions should be tagged according to what makes the question distinctive. For example, a question asking specifically about leveraging similarities between Romance languages should be tagged . A question asking about teaching language features such as tones, cases, etc. should have a tag corresponding to that language feature.

0

Some questions apply naturally just to some language groups. For example, my question What are the pros and cons of learning noun classifiers along with vocabulary? is only useful for languages with classifiers.

However, I don't think that creating tags or questions for language groups is such a good idea.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .